diff --git a/plugins/copyright/src/com/intellij/copyright/CopyrightManager.kt b/plugins/copyright/src/com/intellij/copyright/CopyrightManager.kt
index 083515640292..da4c6e7e98b6 100644
--- a/plugins/copyright/src/com/intellij/copyright/CopyrightManager.kt
+++ b/plugins/copyright/src/com/intellij/copyright/CopyrightManager.kt
@@ -82,13 +82,13 @@ class CopyrightManager @JvmOverloads constructor(private val project: Project, s
 
     override fun isSchemeFile(name: CharSequence) = !StringUtil.equals(name, "profiles_settings.xml")
 
-    override fun getSchemeKey(attributeProvider: Function<String, String?>, fileNameWithoutExtension: String): String? {
+    override fun getSchemeKey(attributeProvider: Function<String, String?>, fileNameWithoutExtension: String): String {
       val schemeKey = super.getSchemeKey(attributeProvider, fileNameWithoutExtension)
       if (schemeKey != null) {
         return schemeKey
       }
       LOG.warn("Name is not specified for scheme $fileNameWithoutExtension, file name will be used instead")
-      return schemeKey
+      return fileNameWithoutExtension
     }
   }, schemeNameToFileName = OLD_NAME_CONVERTER, streamProvider = schemeManagerIprProvider)